{ "by": "incident.synthetic@web-summit.dinis", "updated": "2026-11-11T10:01:17Z", "label": "Invented person; not user research", "persona": "exec", "run": 2, "start": "/welcome/", "steps": [ { "url": "/welcome/", "what": "H1 211 px, lede names Dinis Cruz and AI agents (390 px), buttons 614 px, four figures 700 px; read to the end (2,931 px)", "seconds": 70, "px": 211 }, { "url": "/welcome/#how-it-is-made", "what": "one person instructs, agents write and sign, gate checks, mistakes visible", "seconds": 20, "px": 1583 }, { "url": "/accounts/index.html", "what": "model spend 1.06 of 20 USD cap; provider out of credit since 02:55 UTC; tokens not converted to money", "seconds": 40, "px": 538 }, { "url": "/agents/index.html", "what": "32 agents; What Dinis can unblock: terms doubts at items 2 and 4", "seconds": 25, "px": 295 }, { "url": "/outreach/index.html", "what": "drafts to bodies and journalists; nothing for a newsroom wanting to use it", "seconds": 25, "px": 3695 }, { "url": "/help/cite.html", "what": "Licences: content licence still a known gap", "seconds": 30, "px": 1009 }, { "url": "/board/index.html", "what": "47,352 px, H1 at 28,631 px; closed", "seconds": 10, "px": 28631 } ], "understood_10s": "An experiment: one man and a team of AI agents keeping a sourced public record of a storm in Lisbon; not a warning service.", "understood_1min": "The method (source, time read, labels, open corrections), the proof points (22 minutes, 311 press items) and the outputs (pages, stories, JSON API); not that it is offered as a template.", "looked_for": [ { "what": "What is this and who runs it", "result": "found", "where": "/welcome/ H1 211 px, lede 390 px", "clicks": 0 }, { "what": "Could we reuse it, and what it would cost", "result": "partly", "where": "/welcome/ Take the data ~1,460 px; /accounts/ 538 px (spend vs cap, tokens not money); no reuse offer or contact", "clicks": 1 }, { "what": "Risk: accuracy, licensing, AI policy", "result": "partly", "where": "/welcome/ How it is made 1,583 px; /help/cite.html 1,009 px licence gap; /agents/ 295 px terms doubts", "clicks": 4 } ], "lost": [ "31 agents, 1 editor and a person sends every message suggest human approval of each row; How it is made describes only an automated gate", "Agent count 31 on welcome, 32 on Team, 27 of 31 on Accounts", "Welcome filed under Data room (breadcrumb 151 px)", "Board 47,352 px tall with H1 at 28,631 px", "About still opens /BRIEF.html", "Draft notice: the words are not yet agreed (349 px)" ], "words_not_understood": [ "by-line (for agents)", "capture", "hash", "sha256", "gate", "sign what they push", "weighted tokens", "cache reads", "Panel", "Labs", "Ontology", "Lead times", "IPMA", "ANEPC" ], "would_act": "Forwards /welcome/ to her editor-in-chief as worth a 30-minute call; takes the call only with a reuse block for newsrooms, a stated AI and editorial policy, and a content licence.", "score": 3, "score_reason": "The welcome page answers what this is and who runs it in ten seconds and shows the rigour she wants; it never speaks to a publisher who would reuse it, and licence and terms doubts are unchanged.", "vs_run1": [ { "finding": "1 blocking: no could-my-newsroom-use-this page", "status": "partly" }, { "finding": "2 costly: About goes to the raw brief", "status": "not fixed" }, { "finding": "3 costly: / gives no clue what the site is", "status": "partly" }, { "finding": "4 costly: legal doubts first on Team", "status": "not fixed" }, { "finding": "5 costly: no AI or editorial policy", "status": "partly" }, { "finding": "6 costly: no content licence", "status": "not fixed" }, { "finding": "7 minor: contact route contradiction", "status": "partly" }, { "finding": "8 minor: cost only in tokens", "status": "not fixed" }, { "finding": "9 minor: Studio title below cards", "status": "not checked" }, { "finding": "10 held: Team requests api.github.com", "status": "not fixed" } ], "findings": [ { "class": "costly", "what": "No reuse offer for a newsroom", "where": "/welcome/", "measure": "0 of 5 sections address using it for your own incident; template aim absent", "change": "Add a section: Could this work for your newsroom? What it took, what you get, how to start, who to write to" }, { "class": "costly", "what": "Human review implied, not stated", "where": "/welcome/ 700 px, ~1,620 px, ~1,800 px", "measure": "1 editor and a person sends every message vs gate rebuilds within a minute", "change": "One sentence: what a person checks and what goes live without one" }, { "class": "costly", "what": "Content licence still missing", "where": "/help/cite.html", "measure": "1,009 px, a known gap", "change": "State one and link it from welcome Take the data" }, { "class": "costly", "what": "Cost not in money", "where": "/accounts/", "measure": "538 px, tokens are not converted to money", "change": "A welcome line with running cost in USD, labelled measured or estimated" }, { "class": "costly", "what": "About still the raw brief; welcome filed under Data room", "where": "nav About; /welcome/ breadcrumb", "measure": "About -> /BRIEF.html; breadcrumb 151 px", "change": "Point About at /welcome/; remove the Data room crumb" }, { "class": "minor", "what": "Agent count differs", "where": "/welcome/, /agents/, /accounts/", "measure": "31 vs 32 vs 27 of 31", "change": "One source and one time read" }, { "class": "minor", "what": "Board unusable from welcome", "where": "/board/", "measure": "47,352 px, H1 at 28,631 px", "change": "H1 and a short summary at the top" }, { "class": "minor", "what": "Terms doubts unchanged on Team", "where": "/agents/", "measure": "295 px, items 2 and 4", "change": "As run 1 finding 4" }, { "class": "held", "what": "Draft notice on welcome", "where": "/welcome/", "measure": "349 px", "change": "Remove when the words are agreed" }, { "class": "held", "what": "Team page requests api.github.com", "where": "/agents/", "measure": "external_hosts", "change": "For the team, against the outside-requests rule" } ] }