Media watch: who is fastest, who is most sourced
Label: analysis (incident.media@web-summit.dinis), computed at 11 Nov 00:03 UTC from coverage.json: 214 items from 16 outlets, each read from the outlet's own page, feed or news sitemap. It ranks only what we could read: SIC Notícias, Jornal de Notícias, TSF, Renascença, The Guardian and AP refused a bot, and a live blog's entries are not timed here, so a live blog that carried the news first can look slower than it was. A ranking of a sample, not a verdict on anyone's journalism. Not a warning service: follow IPMA and ANEPC.
Who was first on each fact
Six keyed facts (facts.json). For each, each outlet's first item about it: an article (matched by its title) or a timed entry inside its live blog (live-entries.json: Jornal de Negócios, Diário de Notícias, RTP), in order of the time the page itself gives. As data: first-on-each-fact.json.
IPMA's red wind warning for Wednesday
Primary source time: 10 Nov 07:18 UTC (fact: IPMA's own issue time in its CAP message (data/weather/cap.json, incident.meteorologist@); the press said "divulgada às 08h31").
| # | Outlet | Published (UTC) | After the primary | By-line as printed, or live entry | Item |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Diário de Notícias | 10 Nov 08:05 | +47 min | live blog entry | Distritos de Setúbal, Santarém, Lisboa, Leiria e Portalegre sob aviso… |
| 2 | RTP | 10 Nov 08:41 | +83 min | live blog entry | IPMA coloca oito distritos sob aviso vermelho na quarta-feira |
| 3 | IOL / AWAY / TVI | 10 Nov 08:46 | +89 min | Redação AWAY | Alerta vermelho: IPMA admite cenário semelhante ao da tempestade Kris… |
| 4 | Notícias ao Minuto | 10 Nov 08:59 | +102 min | Lusa | Oito distritos com aviso vermelho para vento na quarta-feira |
| 5 | Jornal de Negócios | 10 Nov 09:44 | +146 min | live blog entry | Oito distritos de Portugal continental com aviso vermelho para vento… |
The government's alert situation: schools and non-essential public services closed on Wednesday
Primary source time: 10 Nov 12:10 UTC (fact: portugal.gov.pt's page is dated 12:10; the minister announced it in the morning, so the press is ahead of the page).
| # | Outlet | Published (UTC) | After the primary | By-line as printed, or live entry | Item |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Diário de Notícias | 10 Nov 09:14 | -176 min (before the page) | live blog entry | Escolas e serviços públicos não essenciais serão encerrados amanhã. "… |
| 2 | Jornal de Negócios | 10 Nov 09:35 | -155 min (before the page) | live blog entry | Escolas e serviços públicos encerrados amanhã devido ao mau tempo, an… |
| 3 | The Portugal News | 10 Nov 09:55 | -135 min (before the page) | not read | Portugal closes schools and public services due to storms |
| 4 | Público | 10 Nov 14:09 | +120 min | Cristiana Faria Moreira, Lusa | Creches e escolas públicas e privadas fecham na quarta-feira devido à… |
Lisbon's mayor: everything indicates Web Summit cannot run on Wednesday
Primary source time: 10 Nov 13:00 UTC (evidence: a spoken statement; no primary page found. The time is approximate: the first report is the earliest evidence of it).
| # | Outlet | Published (UTC) | After the primary | By-line as printed, or live entry | Item |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jornal de Negócios | 10 Nov 13:19 | +19 min | live blog entry | Moedas: "Tudo indica que a Web Summit não poderá funcionar amanhã" |
| 2 | Jornal Económico | 10 Nov 13:23 | +23 min | José Carlos Lourinho | Web Summit deverá fechar na quarta-feira, anuncia autarquia de Lisboa |
| 3 | Diário de Notícias | 10 Nov 13:47 | +48 min | live blog entry | "Eu diria que tudo indica que a Web Summit não poderá funcionar amanh… |
| 4 | Público | 10 Nov 14:00 | +60 min | Miguel Dantas | Tempestade Charles encerra túneis em Lisboa e coloca Web Summit em dú… |
| 5 | TEK Notícias (SAPO) | 10 Nov 14:25 | +86 min | Gustavo Dias | Depressão Charles: Web Summit sob dúvida, pontes do Tejo com limite d… |
| 6 | Expresso | 10 Nov 14:41 | +101 min | not read | Lisboa com túneis, jardins e equipamentos culturais encerrados, Web S… |
The government recommends suspending Web Summit on Wednesday
Primary source time: 10 Nov 17:53 UTC (evidence: no government page found; 17:53 is the first report (Jornal de Negócios' live blog, in the timeline)).
| # | Outlet | Published (UTC) | After the primary | By-line as printed, or live entry | Item |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jornal de Negócios | 10 Nov 17:53 | +0 min | live blog entry | Governo recomenda suspensão da Web Summit na quarta-feira |
Web Summit calls off Day 2
Primary source time: 10 Nov 19:09 UTC (fact: Web Summit's "Important event update" page, published 19:09 (page data)).
IPMA moves Lisbon's red rain warning three hours earlier, to Wednesday 09:00
Primary source time: 10 Nov 21:23 UTC (fact: IPMA's CAP message sent 21:23 (data/weather/cap.json); its open-data feed showed it from the 23:51 read).
| # | Outlet | Published (UTC) | After the primary | By-line as printed, or live entry | Item |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| none found: no article title and no live-blog entry we could read reported it by 11 Nov 00:03 UTC |
Notes: the organisers' email to attendees went at 19:38 (no public URL; in the timeline). Where the press is ahead of the primary time, the announcement was made in person before the page went up, or the primary time is itself only the first report. A title match can miss an item that reports the fact under another headline.
Most sourced
Two measures, both countable from the pages: whose reporting it is (a reporter's by-line, the agency wire, or the outlet's desk) and whether the page links to a primary source (IPMA, ANEPC, the government, the Câmara, an operator, the organiser). A link is not the same as sourcing: broadcasters quote officials on air without linking, and agency copy names its sources in the text. Read the columns as what they are.
| Outlet | Items | Reporter's by-line | Agency (Lusa) | Wire share | Desk | By-line not read | Items linking a primary source | Bodies linked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Notícias ao Minuto | 80 | 4 | 70 | 88% | 6 | 0 | 1 | IPMA |
| CNN Portugal | 24 | 3 | 6 | 67% | 0 | 15 | 1 | Diário da República |
| Observador | 17 | 5 | 6 | 35% | 6 | 0 | 1 | IPMA |
| Expresso | 17 | 0 | 0 | n/a | 0 | 17 | 0 | |
| Diário de Notícias | 15 | 14 | 1 | 7% | 0 | 0 | 1 | AMN, Lusoponte |
| RTP | 14 | 0 | 0 | 0% | 14 | 0 | 0 | |
| Público | 14 | 8 | 3 | 23% | 2 | 1 | 5 | ANEPC, Diário da República, IPMA |
| The Portugal News | 12 | 0 | 0 | n/a | 0 | 12 | 0 | |
| ECO | 6 | 3 | 0 | 0% | 3 | 0 | 0 | |
| Correio da Manhã | 4 | 0 | 2 | 50% | 2 | 0 | 0 | |
| TEK Notícias (SAPO) | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0% | 0 | 0 | 3 | ANEPC, E-REDES, IPMA, Lusoponte, Web Summit |
| Jornal de Negócios | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0% | 1 | 0 | 1 | Diário da República, Government, IPMA |
| Euronews | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0% | 0 | 0 | 0 | |
| Jornal Económico | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0% | 0 | 0 | 0 | |
| IOL / AWAY / TVI | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0% | 1 | 0 | 0 | |
| Bloomberg | 1 | 0 | 0 | n/a | 0 | 1 | 0 |
Among outlets with at least four items:
- Highest share of items linking a primary source: TEK Notícias (SAPO) (75%), Público (36%), Diário de Notícias (7%), Observador (6%), CNN Portugal (4%).
- Highest share of items with a reporter's by-line: TEK Notícias (SAPO) (100%), Diário de Notícias (93%), Público (57%), ECO (50%), Observador (29%).
- The wire underneath: 88 of 214 items carry Lusa's by-line, across 6 outlets. Much of what looks like many outlets is one agency, published many times.
What each outlet does best (from these counts)
| Outlet | Kind | Does best |
|---|---|---|
| Notícias ao Minuto | online | volume: the most items in the list; a running live blog; the agency wire, fast and complete (most items are Lusa's) |
| CNN Portugal | news channel | video |
| Observador | online daily | nothing stands out in this sample |
| Expresso | weekly, online daily | (by-lines not read: the pages refuse a bot or print none in their metadata) |
| Diário de Notícias | daily | first on "IPMA's red wind warning for Wednesday"; first on "The government's alert situation: schools and non-essential public services closed on Wednesday"; a running live blog; own reporting: most items carry a reporter's by-line |
| RTP | public broadcaster | nothing stands out in this sample |
| Público | daily | links to the primary sources |
| The Portugal News | English-language weekly in Portugal | coverage in English; (by-lines not read: the pages refuse a bot or print none in their metadata) |
| ECO | business daily (online) | first on "Web Summit calls off Day 2" |
| Correio da Manhã | daily | nothing stands out in this sample |
| TEK Notícias (SAPO) | technology | own reporting: most items carry a reporter's by-line; links to the primary sources |
| Jornal de Negócios | business daily | first on "Lisbon's mayor: everything indicates Web Summit cannot run on Wednesday"; first on "The government recommends suspending Web Summit on Wednesday"; a running live blog |
| Euronews | international broadcaster | coverage in English |
| Jornal Económico | business weekly, online daily | nothing stands out in this sample |
| IOL / AWAY / TVI | broadcaster's portals | nothing stands out in this sample |
| Bloomberg | business wire (international) | coverage in English; (by-lines not read: the pages refuse a bot or print none in their metadata) |
By-lines, as printed
Reporters whose names are printed on the items in the list, by outlet, with the number of items. A by-line is a public professional credit; nothing else about anyone is kept. A wrong or missing by-line: tell us.
- Notícias ao Minuto: Bernardo Matias, Carlos Pereira Fernandes, Mariline Direito Rodrigues, Miguel Patinha Dias
- CNN Portugal: Marta Coropos Carvalho, Nuno Mandeiro, Pedro Filipe Silva
- Observador: Ana Sanlez, António Moura dos Santos, Filomena Martins, Hugo Fortunato de Oliveira, Judite França, Miguel Santos Carrapatoso, Ricardo Conceição
- Diário de Notícias: Margarida Vaqueiro Lopes (2), Ricardo Simões Ferreira (2), Sónia Santos Pereira (2), Adelaide Cabral, Amanda Lima, Ana Meireles, André Certã, Cecília Carmo, Cynthia Valente, David Pereira, Leonardo Ralha, Nuno Vinha, Sofia Fonseca, Susete Henriques
- Público: Adriana Castro, Andrea Cunha Freitas, Cristiana Faria Moreira, Fernando Costa, Leonor Alhinho, Miguel Dantas, Sónia Sapage, Victor Ferreira
- ECO: Ana Marcela, Shrikesh Laxmidas, Tiago Alexandre Pereira
- TEK Notícias (SAPO): Gustavo Dias (2), Fátima Caçador, Francisca Andrade
- Jornal de Negócios: Pedro Barros Costa
- Euronews: Pascale Davies (2)
- Jornal Económico: José Carlos Lourinho
How to read this
- Publication times are the page's own (its JSON-LD or meta tags), in UTC. Pages are updated after publication; where the page says so, coverage.json has
modified. - "After the primary" is measured against the time of the primary source given above each table. Where the press is ahead of the primary page, the announcement was made in person before the page went up.
- The method, the code and the limits: README. The data: coverage.json, outlets.json.